From “recovery managers” to “green portfolios”

Money does like a quiet environment. But it values clarity and control even more. That is why most international funding for Ukraine’s recovery currently goes to large national projects: roads, major transport routes and energy systems. These offer scale, state guarantees and clear rules.

Meanwhile, small industrial towns with 15,000–30,000 residents, whose lives have revolved around a single mine or factory for decades, remain a “grey area” for an investor in Brussels or London. Too small. Too opaque. Too risky.

The paradox is that these territorial communities (hromadas) need investment most, and it is there that investment can have the greatest impact. Yet the money does not reach them.

The problem is the proposition, rather than a lack of money

Working with industrial communities through the projects “Just Transition of Coal Communities” and “Energy of the Future — New Opportunities for Industrial Communities”, supported by the UK Government, the RCERBS Fund team sees the same picture time and again.

There are enormous resources worldwide for green recovery. Yet very few communities can make a well-founded case for accessing them.

Communities write strategies, hold council sessions and set up working groups. Thick folders labelled “Development Strategy” or “Action Plan” appear in offices. Yet these mean nothing to a bank or investment fund.

A PDF file does not show risks, calculate payback or answer the central question: what exactly are we financing, and how will it generate a return?

Who should do this?

Another problem is staffing. The old management system was not designed for the green transition. Its logic is to spend the budget rather than attract investment.

A new role is therefore emerging in communities: recovery managers. These are not officials in the traditional sense. They are people who understand energy, climate, economics and the language of investors at the same time. Partners are now training them through transformation programmes.

Yet even the best specialist without tools is left alone with a jumble of spreadsheets, letters and paper reports.

How to move beyond this

To break this pattern, communities need digital workspaces: individual dashboards on the Project Navigator platform.

These are used to develop:

• Municipal Energy Plans;

• Environmental Security and Climate Adaptation Strategies;

• waste management plans.

Most importantly, these documents cease to be “lifeless”. Their data are checked, compared and turned into analysis. A community begins to see itself as a system of figures, resources and potential, rather than an area defined by its problems.

When a community becomes visible to an investor

These data are used to build something Ukrainian communities so badly lack: a green investment portfolio.

It is more than a wish list. It is a set of projects, each with:

• a cost;

• an environmental impact;

• a financial rationale;

• alignment with European principles.

This is a language international financial institutions already understand. It is how a community moves from being a “grey area” on the map to a partner whose investment potential can be assessed.

But there is something else investors fear: subjectivity

Even with good data, an investor asks: how do we compare 20 small communities? Which can we trust more?

That is why Project Navigator will introduce another key element: an open community rating.

It will be neither political nor a box-ticking exercise.

It will be based on real indicators:

• how data are updated;

• whether plans are implemented;

• whether projects are ready;

• whether there is a team;

• whether the financial rationale is transparent.

Communities will start competing on the quality of their management and their readiness for investment, rather than on their “friendship with the ministry”.

This creates something Ukraine has lacked for years: healthy competition between small communities.

People are the real resource

At the centre of this system, however, are people, rather than platforms or ratings.

The very energy managers, project specialists and activists who have shouldered change in small industrial towns for years. They cannot match large corporations in money or connections, but they have greater motivation.

The task of just transition programmes is to make these driving forces visible. To give them tools that put them on an equal footing with major players.

Then Ukraine’s green recovery will become an investment reality, moving beyond a slogan.

Ruslan Shcherbakov, President of the RCERBS Fund

Need support with preparing a strategic document?Contact the Fund