The World Bank has extensive experience of implementing recovery projects after natural disasters and conflicts in different regions and contexts. This experience should be used to ensure that Ukraine’s reconstruction addresses all aspects of life through a comprehensive, holistic and multidimensional process. Success depends on combining physical reconstruction with the rule of law, good governance, stronger democratic institutions and societal recovery.
Vladlena Martsynkevych, Project Manager, Ukraine Reconstruction | 11 November 2024
Ukraine is currently charting its path towards recovery and reconstruction. The national recovery strategy needs clear priorities, a coherent vision for the country’s development and mechanisms that ensure inclusive participation from the bottom up. The World Bank can strengthen Ukraine’s national recovery strategy by increasing its involvement in programme financing.
This requires the following measures:
-
Ensure appropriate engagement of the public and subnational groups involved in the recovery process.
-
This includes updating the Rapid Damage and Needs Assessment report, particularly regarding damage and needs in municipalities.
-
Ensure appropriate engagement of the public and subnational groups involved in the recovery process.
-
This includes updating the Rapid Damage and Needs Assessment report, particularly regarding damage and needs in municipalities.
-
Promote meaningful cooperation and partnerships with civil society in local decision-making. This is key to effective and inclusive local development.
-
Translate environmental commitments into practical measures and plans. These must be integrated into public investment management (PIM) financing criteria to support both current urgent needs and long-term post-war recovery efforts.
Public investment management in Ukraine: A system taking shape
The World Bank provides both financial support for Ukraine’s struggle for territorial integrity and democratic values and technical support for implementing reforms. According to the findings of the World Bank’s diagnostic report on Ukraine’s public financial management system, implementation of public investment management reform is under way.
A PIM roadmap was developed at the end of 2023. By 2024, an action plan for its implementation had been approved and the Strategic Investment Council established. The roadmap identifies local authorities as equal partners in implementing this reform alongside the Ministries of Finance, Economy and Infrastructure, other central government bodies, the State Agency for Reconstruction and Development, the Accounting Chamber and the State Audit Service. However, the action plan contains only a few community-related measures, and these are advisory.
Representatives of local self-government and civil society are currently not involved in the work of the Strategic Investment Council. However, Resolution No. 549, adopted by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on 14 May 2024, explicitly provides that the Council may engage and cooperate with representatives of executive authorities, Members of Parliament of Ukraine, local self-government bodies, enterprises, institutions, organisations, independent experts, the public and the media.
Why is it important to ensure local self-government has an active role in implementing financial investment management reform?
Since 2022, Ukraine has received significantly more international financial assistance for the state budget. Yet almost none of this funding goes directly to local budgets. Municipalities, which are closest to people, have to address crises such as destroyed infrastructure, people’s relocation or evacuation, the provision of basic social services and support for critical infrastructure. These tasks require additional financial resources.
Funding from international financial institutions for municipal reconstruction currently passes through intermediaries. For example, the European Investment Bank provides financing through the Ministry of Reconstruction as transfers from the state budget to local budgets; the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development distributes loans through Ukrainian commercial banks; and the World Bank supports the state budget by funding salaries, pensions and basic services such as healthcare and education.
Direct interaction between municipalities and international financial institutions would enable a faster response to wartime challenges and reduce time spent on bureaucratic procedures. At the same time, municipalities must be ready for such interaction: they need to be proactive, prepare high-quality project applications and ensure effective financial management.
Where does the World Bank stand?
The World Bank’s Board of Directors recently approved SURGE (Supporting Reconstruction through Smart Fiscal Governance). This project will use the Program-for-Results financing instrument, which should significantly improve interaction between national and local stakeholders in the public investment management system. Ensuring public participation in these processes is critical to transparency and fair resource allocation.
Proposals to improve municipalities’ access to decision-making and financial resources:
-
Increase the participation of local authorities, which currently lack systematic and sustained involvement in public investment management reform.
-
Improve strategic project selection by developing a clear methodology for selecting national strategic projects.
-
Promote ongoing multistakeholder dialogue by supporting communication between national authorities, local territorial communities (hromadas), non-governmental organisations and other stakeholders.
-
Integrate sustainable development into PIM goals and objectives to support climate-oriented recovery.
On 22 October, participants at Bankwatch’s event “The World Bank’s Role in Supporting Ukraine’s Recovery” discussed these critical issues and learned valuable lessons from Georgia’s post-war reconstruction experience. Particular attention was paid to PIM reform, the participation of local self-government and civil society in resource allocation, and previous experience of applying international financial institutions’ standards in Ukraine.
The success of Ukraine’s reconstruction depends on proper implementation of PIM reform and municipalities’ direct involvement in decision-making. The SURGE programme can help establish transparent mechanisms for project selection and resource allocation. However, without systematic participation by local authorities and civil society, the integration of sustainability considerations and a transparent methodology for selecting strategic projects, reconstruction efforts may prove ineffective.
