“Three Questions about Recovery” is the name of a media project launched by the civil society organisations Fund “Regional Center for Economic Research and Business Support” (RCERBS) from Lubny and Ecoaction from Kyiv. They invite everyone who cares about the recovery of territorial communities (hromadas) in Ukraine to take part.

This series will explore how community recovery problems are being addressed, giving a voice to everyone who wishes to share their perspective. Three questions about recovery will be answered by experts from various fields, volunteers, researchers, entrepreneurs, civil society activists, municipal workers, civil servants, farmers, military personnel, educators, healthcare professionals and schoolchildren. RCERBS and Ecoaction seek practical proposals and ideas from citizens.

This article explores how the Fund “Regional Center for Economic Research and Business Support” helped Petropavlivka community in Dnipropetrovsk Oblast develop a Comprehensive Recovery Programme focused on the green economy.

Communities now face numerous challenges, including infrastructure destruction and social and economic problems caused by the war and long-standing dependence on the coal industry. We will learn about these difficulties and possible solutions through the answers to our questions.

Answers from Olena Hryhorevska, Head of the Economic Development and Investment Activities Sector of Petropavlivka territorial community, Dnipropetrovsk Oblast

Olena Hryhorevska

— What mattered most to your team when you began developing the Comprehensive Recovery Programme (CRP)? Olena Hryhorevska: — In its comprehensive recovery plan, Petropavlivka community identified key priorities for restoring the area, particularly in spatial planning, urban development and socioeconomic development. The plan includes measures to restore the parts of the community most affected by socioeconomic, infrastructure and environmental problems. The community’s priorities changed with the start of the war: shelling damaged residential and public buildings, adding new recovery challenges. The main goal became the development of a document and a plan to restore utility infrastructure and create conditions for education, culture, sport, healthcare, safety and social protection. There is also a focus on improving the environment and protecting natural resources, taking account of the community’s strategic documents, such as the “Municipal Energy Plan to 2030”, the “Environmental Security and Climate Adaptation Strategy to 2030”, the “Development Strategy for 2024–2029”, the “Concept for Adapting Healthcare Infrastructure” and the “Social Services Development Strategy for 2021–2027”. — How did you work with proposals from the public? Olena Hryhorevska: — After deciding to develop a Comprehensive Recovery Programme (CRP) and form a working group, the next step was a survey of citizens and businesses. This survey enabled us to collect hundreds of proposals from more than 200 people, including ideas to restore a bakery, complete the construction of a 45-flat residential building, reconstruct the water supply system, create a waste sorting station and build factories on existing property complexes following the closure of DTEK’s mines (to provide new jobs and retrain miners), install solar power plants, and carry out various environmental and social projects.

The working group’s organisers tried to make the process as simple as possible. In addition to publishing the questionnaire on the community website and the Strimko UA NGO’s Facebook page, they held several meetings with the public and businesses, discussed proposals and issued a number of publications. The analysis of proposals went beyond a standard approach, also focusing on solutions that support a just transition for the coal community and its sustainable development. — What is the “Green Map”? Olena Hryhorevska: — Together with the RCERBS Fund from Lubny, the working group created a “Green Map” of priority measures for Petropavlivka community. This map sets goals aligned with the UN Global Goals supported by Ukraine. The “Green Map” includes 18 priority projects recommended by community residents, businesspeople, experts, municipal staff and Ukraine’s state authorities. In total, the Comprehensive Recovery Programme (CRP) envisages 86 community development projects to 2030.

Answers from Ruslan Shcherbakov, President of the NGO Fund “Regional Center for Economic Research and Business Support” (RCERBS), Lubny

Ruslan Shcherbakov

— You help communities find the right solutions for recovery and development. How does your organisation select those it will work with?

Ruslan Shcherbakov: — Our project, launched in 2017, is called “Organising Cooperation between Small Ukrainian Towns, Civil Society and Experts on Energy Security”. Over these seven years, more than a hundred organisations, mainly communities, have joined it. We work with these communities, helping them prepare recovery plans, Municipal Energy Plans and Environmental Security and Climate Adaptation Strategies. We also help implement projects chosen by the communities themselves. When donor funding is available, we select communities that are most actively seeking to develop. Without funding, we help as far as we can. — What difficulties do you experience when working with communities? Ruslan Shcherbakov: — Most small and medium-sized communities have weak strategic planning. This stems from several factors, such as

  • insufficient motivation among local managers,

  • a lack of understanding of economic processes within the community,

  • disregard for the interests of different population groups

  • and political short-sightedness.

Community leaders recognise that, apart from the war, the main problem is a lack of funding. Yet only some take a creative approach to finding additional resources, although opportunities do exist. — What would you advise community leaders in this situation? Ruslan Shcherbakov: — Engage experts to prepare project proposals. Some countries even fund the involvement of experts in recovery. Delegate responsibilities: build a team, motivate people and do not try to solve everything yourself. Show the community what awaits it after the war ends, and actively consult its residents. Do not be afraid of their opinions, and treat people as partners in development rather than critics of your actions.

In our view, these three aspects are the foundation of a community’s success today.

Answers from Anastasiia Bushovska, energy policy and just transition specialist at the NGO Ecoaction

— How do you see the role of local civil society organisations in the recovery of coal communities during the war? Anastasiia Bushovska: — Firstly, they have a deep understanding of their communities’ specific needs and problems, enabling them to develop and implement more effective solutions. Secondly, local organisations can actively involve the public in recovery, helping initiatives gain better understanding and support. Ecoaction held a call for transformative projects implemented by civil society organisations to support a just transition in coal communities. These projects aim to support communities in moving from a coal-based economy to a more sustainable, green economy. Ecoaction provides financial and expert support for implementing such projects. Civil society organisations also play an important role in sharing information and raising public awareness of the opportunities and benefits of a just transition. They can organise training, consultations and exchanges of experience, supporting more effective and sustainable community development. Their flexibility and closeness to local people enable civil society organisations to respond quickly to changing circumstances and adapt effectively to new challenges. — What main challenges do you see in a community’s transition from a coal-based to a green economy? Anastasiia Bushovska: — From our experience of working on a just transition and cooperating with coal communities, we observe:

  • limited relevant expertise within communities and limited external expert support,

  • insufficient communication about the energy transition process and coordination between different levels of government and within communities,

  • limited access to funding for communities and limited investment, exacerbated during wartime.

As a result, communities face the challenge of realistically planning measures that will help them carry out an energy transition through sustainable, systemic solutions — for residents, the environment and the energy system — while also creating new and, where possible, green jobs.

Experience from other countries or even other Ukrainian communities, and the opportunity to engage external experts, are useful here. At Ecoaction, we help coal communities by providing recommendations based on other countries’ experience and EU requirements and best practices, helping them find experts and exchange experience, supporting pilot projects, and providing training and consultations for community and civil society organisation representatives. All this helps communities choose more sustainable solutions and jointly move towards a just transition. Smaller communities struggle to compete for project funding, and available funds cannot always be used, for example, to develop programme documents during wartime. This is where civil society organisations can help. Ideally, a community has its own civil society organisation, creating opportunities to attract additional funding for community development. But organisations from elsewhere can also be ready to support communities with their expertise, as in the case of Petropavlivka community and the RCERBS Fund. — Are there many communities in Ukraine successfully implementing Comprehensive Recovery Programmes? Anastasiia Bushovska: — Among coal communities, we know of several recovery planning documents. Myrnohrad community in Donetsk Oblast is currently developing a recovery and development plan despite being 15 km from the combat zone, with a focus, naturally, on safety and resilience. Novovolynsk and Petropavlivka communities have developed Comprehensive Recovery Programmes that include just transition measures. Since both documents were developed only recently, it is too early to assess the success of their implementation. They are, however, excellent examples of how a coal community’s just transition can be incorporated into recovery — these processes are inseparable if we are to build back better. Share your thoughts and ideas on community recovery in Ukraine! RCERBS and Ecoaction invite you to join the “Three Questions about Recovery” media project. Your proposals and experience can make an important contribution to Ukraine’s development and recovery. To participate, please email lubnyfound@gmail.com.

RCERBS and Ecoaction aim to create a platform for exchanging ideas and jointly seeking solutions that support effective community recovery.

Need support with preparing a strategic document?Contact the Fund