Over the past few years, Ukrainian territorial communities (hromadas) have gradually been learning to work in a new way. While development previously often came down to ad hoc decisions and competition for individual subsidies, today more and more municipalities are moving towards systematic planning.

Communities are preparing Local Waste Management Plans (LWMPs), Municipal Energy Plans (MEPs), Environmental Security and Climate Adaptation Strategies, and action plans for their implementation. All this means one important thing: communities are beginning to accumulate data, analysis and an understanding of their own problems and resources, rather than simply a collection of documents.

Today, however, it is becoming clear that strategies alone are no longer enough.

A document is only the beginning

Just a few years ago, having a strategy or plan was itself considered a success. For many communities, it was indeed a major step forward. Gradually, however, both donor requirements and the approaches of international financial institutions have changed.

The world no longer funds a mere “intention to improve something”. Investors and partners want to see concrete results and an economic rationale. They want to see an impact on the community, environmental benefits and realistic prospects for implementation.

That is why, after preparing strategic documents, communities inevitably move to the next stage — building investment portfolios.

In effect, this is a transition from “we know our problems” to “here is a solution we are ready to implement”.

Why not every idea is an investment project

This is where many communities begin to encounter difficulties.

A typical situation looks like this: after preparing an LWMP or MEP, a community tries to put together a “project portfolio” quickly. It often uses old material — projects that have been “on the shelf” for years, old concepts or archived applications.

On paper, this looks like a ready foundation. The problem, however, is that many of these ideas were developed for very different circumstances and often no longer meet current requirements.

New ideas from residents, entrepreneurs or activists are even more challenging. They may be relevant and promising, but lack completed calculations, technical documentation or a clear structure. As a result, they are often set aside in favour of “old folders”.

Consequently, communities frequently assemble a collection of disparate projects rather than an investment portfolio.

But the modern logic of public investment works differently.

From “repairs” to public benefit

Today, international financial institutions increasingly assess both the facility itself and the effect it creates for the community.

For example:

  • replacing a boiler is not yet an energy transformation;

  • repairing a building does not always mean development;

  • purchasing equipment does not necessarily solve a problem systematically.

The focus is gradually shifting to other questions:

  • whether the project creates new capacity for the community;

  • whether it has a long-term impact;

  • whether it addresses environmental and climate challenges;

  • whether it has an economic justification.

Ukrainian communities are now beginning to adapt to this logic.

A new approach to project assessment

As part of the development of Project Navigator, with support from Bankwatch Network and partners at the NGO Ecoaction, an approach to assessing communities’ project proposals has been developed.

Its main purpose is to help municipalities move from a formal approach to project preparation towards a public investment system focused on results, long-term impact and modern European environmental principles.

In practice, this is more than “assessing applications”. It is about creating a new culture of preparing municipal decisions.

This approach considers a project’s alignment with the community’s strategic documents, the feasibility of implementation, public benefit, environmental impact, readiness for funding and consistency with modern “green” approaches.

Particular attention is planned for projects that both “address a problem” and bring a new quality of community development.

Environmental sustainability is becoming the new norm

Another important change is that the environmental component is gradually ceasing to be an “additional advantage”.

For many international programmes, it is already becoming a basic condition of access to funding.

That is why the following are increasingly important when building portfolios:

a) climate adaptation;

b) energy efficiency;

c) waste management;

d) Do No Significant Harm (DNSH) principles;

e) environmental impact assessment.

This goes beyond environmental issues. It concerns a community’s competitiveness in the struggle for resources.

What this means for communities

Ukrainian communities are, in effect, entering a new phase of development. The period when it was enough simply to write a strategy or prepare a “project for a funding call” is gradually coming to an end.

What lies ahead is competition over the quality of preparation of solutions.

That is why building project portfolios is becoming a logical continuation of LWMPs, MEPs and climate strategies. A strategy without an investment follow-up risks remaining just a document.

A project portfolio, in turn, is the language a community begins to use when engaging with the world of investment and partnerships.

Would you like to learn more about taking part in a programme?Contact the Fund